Sentinel by Hashicorp

vs. tfRails

Sentinel by Hashicorp
vs.
TF Rails
Sentinel by Hashicorp
vs. tfRails
Detailed comparison for terraform testing
Sentinel by Hashicorp
vs. Tf-Rails
Architecture
The main distinctions between IaC testing tools arise from their ability to perform impact analysis against the runtime environment, considering potential resource drift, and to evaluate impacts beyond the unit level. Focusing solely on unit-level testing may lead to overlooking critical issues or generating false-positive alerts.
tfRails
Sentinel by Hashicorp
Merges runtime and build
Yes
No
Full posture impact analysis
Yes
No
OpenSource
No
No (Terraform Enterprise)

Sentinel is a policy as code framework developed by HashiCorp that enables users to define, manage, and enforce policies across their infrastructure and applications. It operates as a rules engine that evaluates policies against requests made to various HashiCorp tools, including Terraform, Nomad, and Vault, and makes decisions based on those policies. Sentinel is designed to be flexible and extensible, allowing users to define policies in their preferred language, including HCL, JSON, YAML, and others. It supports a variety of use cases, such as preventing users from launching non-compliant infrastructure, ensuring compliance with regulatory standards, and enforcing access controls. Sentinel's architecture consists of a set of rules and policies defined by the user, a runtime engine responsible for evaluating those rules and policies against incoming requests, and a policy authoring and management interface. Sentinel also provides integration points for other tools and services, enabling users to extend their policy coverage beyond the HashiCorp ecosystem.

Sentinel by Hashicorp
vs. Tf-Rails
Use Case
When selecting a Terraform testing tool, it is essential to ensure that the tool is capable of addressing various use cases to thoroughly assess critical elements of a change, such as Availability, Resilience, Security, and Cost.
tfRails
Sentinel by Hashicorp
User defined policies
No code solution | supporting posture based rules
Code, focused on unit level
Rules categories
Cost, Security, Resilience
Security, Cost

Sentinel covers the following use casesInfrastructure as code (IaC) compliance: Sentinel can be used to define and enforce policies that ensure infrastructure deployments adhere to organizational standards, best practices, and compliance regulations. For example, Sentinel can enforce policies related to network security, access control, and data protection.Access control: Sentinel can be used to enforce access control policies that restrict access to sensitive data and resources. This can include policies that require multi-factor authentication, restrict access based on location or device, and ensure that only authorized personnel have access to critical resources.Cost management: Sentinel can be used to enforce policies that help organizations manage cloud costs by ensuring that resources are provisioned efficiently and in line with organizational requirements. This can include policies that enforce tagging standards, limit the creation of expensive resources, and ensure that unused resources are deleted.Compliance and regulatory requirements: Sentinel can be used to enforce policies that ensure compliance with various regulatory requirements, such as HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR. This can include policies that ensure sensitive data is encrypted, audit logs are retained, and access to sensitive data is restricted.Custom policies: Sentinel is highly flexible and can be used to define custom policies tailored to specific organizational requirements. For example, Sentinel can be used to enforce policies related to naming conventions, resource quotas, and service level agreements (SLAs).

Sentinel by Hashicorp
vs. Tf-Rails
Coverage
When evaluating IaC testing tools, support for multiple languages may seem like a desirable feature; however, it is less important than the tool's overall quality. A high-quality tool should prioritize accurate and comprehensive tests for a specific language, ensuring better issue detection and reducing false positives. In essence, it's better to have an effective testing tool for one language than a mediocre one for multiple languages.
tfRails
Sentinel by Hashicorp
Supported IaC
No code solution | Terraform
Terraform
Supported cloud
AWS
AWS, Azure, GCP